Here we go again folks. And I apologize in advance to all of you who miss the simpler jljj blog days when I wasn’t so angry and ranty all of the time (they are bound to return, just not today.) Sorry to all of you who would rather hear funny stories about how the Seal ate a whole bag of glow in the dark stars a few days ago and has since been pooping constellations. Or how I got in one of the biggest twitter battles of my life this weekend because lesbians cannot handle reasonable fashion policing, even from their own kind (oh no she did not just say that! Only I just did.) If you are thinking “Enough with the newsworthy queer-rights-gone-wrong political ranting!” I suggest you click away now.
Because once again, I AM FURIOUS about the latest happenings in regards to Constance McMillen and the unbelievable, undeniable, blatant, in-all-y’alls-queer-faggot-dyke-faces hate that has gone on and ceases to astound the safer, well-armored pieces of my being.
Now, here’s what happened:
Constance McMillen was invited to a fake prom. Constance, her girlfriend and 5 other kids, two of whom are being recognized as having “learning difficulties,” were invited to a, since realized, ‘fake’ prom, in which Principal Fuckall Wiygul and a few teachers chaperoned, but who I’m sure were all more than happy to stand there proudly while watching the homos, the freaks and the slow kids dancing alone, knowing full well that the rest of the entire senior class, with the good, normal, god-fearing children and parents, were at a secret, different prom: the ‘real’ prom.
That is what happened.
That was their response as a community. That is how the school district, the town citizens, neighbors, friends, students and parents decided to deal with this one lesbian girl who wanted to bring her girlfriend to a school dance. Yes sir, they duped a teenaged girl and a few of the slower kids into attending a fake event while everyone else knowingly attended the real one. That is what they did.
And I know after I take a few deep breaths, after a few days I’ll find myself once again capable of having a reasonable conversation about my philosophies for possible systemic change and positive ways to influence community at a grassroots level. Maybe. But right now? Right now I am so beyond trying to swallow this one.
Every day I get up and for some reason or another, in some moment or a few, I have to fight a little, stand up a bit at least, JUST TO BE ME. I’ll call Violet sweetie in the grocery store and when that guy stares at me, well, I’ve spent years now practicing how to be brave enough to stare back and not to let myself look away until after he does. And just peeing in a public place, anywhere, for me is a sort of non-consensual act of activism: me with a full bladder versus your idea of ‘female’. And I am not whining here, most of us do this in some form or another, for a million different reasons, everywhere, every day. Every single day. We wake up, we brush our teeth and then we put on some combination and specific variety of armor that let’s us walk out the front door without dying, so that we can take the blows if and when they come. Fine. That’s life and that isn’t the point here.
But sometimes I feel like my anger just falls over a breaking point and it shatters and I don’t even feel it, like right now. I’m just so profoundly sad that I feel like I can’t get enough air into my own chest. Like right now.
Right now I just want to put my hands up in the air and trade in my rainbow flag for a white one so that I can wave it back and forth and say, “You know what? Fuck it. I am so exhausted and I am not willing to fight half as dirty as you just did SO YOU WIN. Now please… please leave me alone.
And the worst part? I know that all of this anger I feel towards all of you who pulled this fake prom shit on Constance, that let Matthew Shepard get beaten up and murdered over and over, again and again and again, that have little kids killing themselves because no one is stopping the homophobic bullying, that protest and vote and preach against queer rights, my rights, this blind rage that I feel, and I do mean rage, that I have and hold and carry and wear all of the time, all towards all of you who do this, aimed right at you specifically, without giving a shit about who you are or your story or what your name is even…
I know that’s how you feel about me too.
That’s how you feel about Constance. And so when you hurt me, when you kick us down, scare us, scar us, piss us off, taunt us, harass us, warn us, threaten us, intimidate us, and bully us, when you get us so upset that we can’t sleep, like tonight (this morning)- you won and I lost.
And then, when some gay-marriage rights pass in some state we won, you lost
And then you’ll fire my friend from his job because he’s trans and you’ll get away with it and you’ll get excited and go after the next one. And I’ll turn red in the face all over again, unable to do anything about it except put my hands up in the air and shake my head, back and forth, back and forth. Like right now.
And round and round we’ll go… where we’ll stop?…
Right now, today, my hands are up. You got me. Holy shit, you got me. Eventually my hands will find their way back to my hips, and when they do, watch the fuck out. But today, my hands are up.

24 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 6, 2010 at 6:09 am
ABtflDisaster
j~ yesterday when i read bits and pieces about what happened, i was angry. i thought, well shit, i went to a PRIVATE CHRISTIAN SCHOOL and while i wasn’t out yet, i took girls to TWO FUCKIN proms…not to mention the countless homecomings!!! was it different because they were friends, sure, but the fact is i still took girls. and no one said anything. i know that had i been out things would have been different and this saddens me. but thats beside the point of why i am even commenting.
i wouldn’t call myself an activist. i stand up for what i believe in and will fight tooth and nail against bigots and fucktards. because this is my *right* as a living, breathing, human. i don’t stand in the picket lines, or march down the street, and i’ve never been to a rally. i donate to causes fighting for my rights as a woman, a human, a partner, a daughter, a friend, a sister, an aunt, a lesbian. i wear tshirts about equal rights and being above the hatred. I have an equality sticker on my jeep. i wear a rainbow colored friendship bracelet. i proudly hold my butch’s hand and kiss her beautiful face in public. because i am human before i am a lesbian. and that is my GOD GIVEN right. but i wouldn’t call myself an activist. i am just me. living in my moment.
your post today hurts my heart. i’ve been there. i’ve thrown up my hands with tears running down my face-the desire to fight long gone. i have fallen to my knees and surrendered. after-all, being femme, i come out again and again every single day. however when i get back up, my fight is stronger. the desire deeper. and the passion…well as you said-watch the fuck out. so today, i am sending comforting thoughts your way. sending empowering energy to you through the miles. what doesn’t kill us, makes us stronger….
…hugs to you my friend…
April 6, 2010 at 3:58 pm
jessejames
“I am a human before I am a lesbian.” How simple. How obvious. How wonderful for you to put that in this context. Thanks for the comment. I really appreciate it.
April 7, 2010 at 5:58 am
ABtflDisaster
While I tend to roll my eyes in play at my girlfriend every time she says “I’m not a lesbian, that’s just how society has labeled me….Why must everything and everyone have a label?” -she does have a point. We are human before we are anything or anyone else. It’s sad to me that something so simple and obvious, as you said, can also be forgotten.
I hope that you are feeling….better, more centered today.
April 6, 2010 at 6:12 pm
ash-a-frash
yes! those in charge are so quick to give labels, yet they forget our humanity. beautifully written!
NEVER SURRENDER!
April 6, 2010 at 6:18 am
Blazer
I understand your rage, your frustration, your wanting to wave the white flag and throw in the towel. Why do we have to keeping fighting just to be ourselves, love who we love, exist? But like you, my hands will drop to my sides, my fists clenched and we will keep on doing the work for Constance and every other queer kid, so maybe they won’t have to fight quite so much.
April 6, 2010 at 4:14 pm
jessejames
That’s what it’s all about huh? Doing the work now (i.e. being ourselves without apology) so that maybe the kids that start a GSA club at their high school two years from now (I am being hopeful to counter-blaance) can definitely, without a doubt, go to the prom with whomever they want, wearing whatever makes them feel right and then all of our stories, Constance’s story, becomes just that, just a story about ‘the way it was.’ Maybe?
April 6, 2010 at 7:01 am
greg
JJ, you have an army behind you. We all carry eachother, buddy. You’re perfectly fine to sit and gather strength when you need it.
April 6, 2010 at 7:43 am
Sweetspiced
You know – you should be angry. Because NO ONE should have to deal with this. I’m pissed. And I’ve lived in the “straight” world my whole life so I’ve been sheltered. But hatred and bigotry and this kind of mockery are insane. NUTS. Sorry. As you can see I too am a bit pissed off.
The thing is it shouldn’t ever be a problem to love someone, or to be different, or to be slow. And that a town would do that, a WHOLE town – would rise up to trick someone. To in a very real sense say you’re not okay, you’re not “human” enough. BULL SHIT.
I’d like to take each one of them and make an example of them. But you’re right. We can’t. And that pisses me off too. I’ve never been a fan of militancy because it’s always seemed reverse bigotry – but damn it bring me some barbed wire. I’ve got a few people to string up. Namely those parents who’ve taught their children that it’s okay to hate someone – that that taught them that there is a “normal” and anyone outside of it deserves to be ridiculed and shunned.
GAH. Okay. I will calm down. Later. But I don’t blame you for the rant – I blame them for the need to be righteously angry.
April 6, 2010 at 9:50 am
e
Thanks for ranting, jj. We are all joining you. I read this shit and i couldn’t believe it. Couldn’t believe that a whole town would collude like this to trick these kids. Un-fucking-believable.
I am sad. And discouraged. And angry. I’m trying not to hate, but it’s hard. I’ll never understand these people, and on many levels, I don’t really want to understand them. I don’t want to understand WHY they feel justified in this behaviour. At this moment, I would rather just set fire to their town. But, I won’t. Because I’m not like them.
I hope Constance and her girl friend get away from there. Move somewhere that the hate isn’t so overt. Sure, we all know that they will need a thick skin to live openly queer in our world, but they shouldn’t have to put up with this.
April 6, 2010 at 11:46 am
jesse james
No, no one should have to put up with this. My head is still spinning. How sad that maybe the only real solution for her is to move away from her hometown. I mean, that’s what I had to do, a lot of us had to. But then, now I go back there to sit in on GSA meetings In a HS that use to terrify me- and that too still has my head spinning.
April 6, 2010 at 11:23 am
You’ve got to be fucking kidding « dyke evolution
[...] many emotions and feelings and opinions that I feel paralyzed, without a place to begin. So go read Jesse Jame’s posted about it, and Tina’s, and G’s. Thanks for taking the time out to put my thoughts [...]
April 6, 2010 at 11:24 am
dykeevolution
Really ridiculously fucking sick. My head hurts from all of the rage that was surging through me this morning. Now, I’m just so sad.
April 6, 2010 at 12:30 pm
Jude
I’ve read several stories about this now. That principle, the teachers, the parents must be feeling pretty slick that they pulled off the secret real prom. What a bunch of hating A-holes living in the bible belt….ppffffttt!
But there’s one thing that is gnawing me and that is why didn’t Constance get a heads up from one friend who was at the real prom? I don’t get that part.
April 6, 2010 at 2:28 pm
Kim
I am just sitting here shaking my head. What is it, the f*king fifties? And how old are the principal and staff, f*king twelve years old? Yes, it is all the things you have all said above – bigotry, intolerance, a violation of human rights etc, etc… but even beyond that, honestly, how could grown adults behave in such a childish manner and be proud of themselves? They must be very seriously emotionally impaired. I am just shaking my head. I don’t understand at all. It’s like they dropped through a hole in the space/time continuum, straight from the site of a 1950s lynching, and landed in 2010 at Constance’s school. I just cannot believe this is how educated adults behave. I am truly shocked.
JJ, if it makes you feel even slightly better at all, I was reflecting yesterday, having spent quite a lot of time over the past few weeks (and years) visiting various elderly relatives and in-laws in hospitals here in Australia, that not once has anyone even blinked when I refer to my (now ex) same-sex partner as ‘my partner’, and not once, across a large number of hospitals of both the public and private variety, not once, has my partner’s right to be there or to obtain information from the doctors or nurses been challenged. Not once. We have truly not been treated any differently to a straight couple. So it’s not shit everywhere, JJ.
Cold comfort I guess, but it’s the best I can do this early in the morning. I understand your rage. Hugs.
April 6, 2010 at 4:08 pm
JMc
Yup, watch the fuck out when we all ready ourselves for the next round… because we will be wiser, stronger and have more allies than before because of the low-down, dirty way things were handled. The tide IS turning.
April 6, 2010 at 5:41 pm
jessejames
Right. I was chatting with greg today and she said something to the effect of, “well, they (the awful adults involved) are making themselves look quite evil.” Indeed they are. I just hope that their next court hearings really make it publicly and legally obvious how inapropriate the adults have been. Some of the kids suck too, obviously. I mean, like Jude mentioned, how in the WORLD did NONE of the students tell Constance about the ‘real’ prom? But, they are just kids. It’s the adults that need some real reprimanding (dear gawd, please fire all of them, thanks, jesse). Not only are they suppose to be grown-ups but they are also the school officials! Ugh. Ok, I’m just making myself mad again.
Yes, the tide is turning… a bit.
April 7, 2010 at 5:31 am
fungirls
Cry in our beers together sometime soon?
April 6, 2010 at 6:40 pm
Benjamin_Beks
you know what the worst fucking thing about this whole debacle was for me?
i wasn’t the least bit surprised. after reading that the parents put together this shrine to the acme of douchebaggery, i wasn’t in the least bit shocked at this. i’m not from fulton, mississippi. but i’ve still grown up around these people. i’ve grown up around their cruelty, their ignorance, their willingness to be blind to the growing world around them. they’re like a bad STD, once you they’re around, it’s pretty damn hard to get rid of them. there is nothing more powerful than stubborn southern malice.
am i disgusted? yes. am i deeply saddened? yes. but i’m not shocked, and i’m not enraged, because anger does nothing but blind me. i learned a long time ago not to react with anger to these people, because that only makes them more powerful, because at least they got a reaction. these people are worse than filth. filth can be cleaned up, these people are beyond redemption and beyond change in my opinion, and their kids are on their way to being the same way?
you wanna know why no one said anything to constance? because deep down in their douchebag hearts, they selfishly wanted their prom to be ‘perfect’ so twenty years down the road when they’re still flipping burgers with a double-wide full of illegitimate children, they can remember that shining moment where they got to be drunk, dance, and not worry about some ghey ruining their life.
okay, rant over. i’m just going to sit back and let the media expose these douchecakes even further, and follow constance’s example and handle things with grace and courage, because honestly, that’s all we really can do.
April 7, 2010 at 8:31 am
Vikki
There’s not much I can say that hasn’t been said. Sad. Infuriating. Horrible. Unbelievable. It’s all those things and more.
April 7, 2010 at 2:02 pm
So What’s Next?: McMillen’s Fake Prom – Sugarbutch Chronicles
[...] probably already heard this. Jesse James had a nice post on it, Dorothy Snarker posted something [...]
April 7, 2010 at 4:29 pm
K-K
I read your post yesterday but decided to wait a day to comment so that maybe I would calm down and get some perspective. Didn’t calm down much and I don’t know if my perspective is any better but I’m going to comment anyway. Constance lives in my neck of the woods so I’m not surprised by what transpired. The school officials and parents that pulled this off are supremely proud of themselves. They showed everyone (the judicial system,the ACLU, America and the world). In their collective mind think that is what had to be done. In other words welcome to the deep south. The hubris these people exibited is ubiquitous in this region of the USA. I am surrounded by it. They honestly believe they did the right thing and dare anyone to tell them different. If someone does they will go out of their way to show you that they can and will do it their way with no regard for the consequences to themselves or others. This self rightous behaviour is pervasive in rural Miss., La, Tx. etc. Believe me I have had the pleasure of their company for my entire life. You may ask why I don’t I move. The reason being that for every person that thinks and acts in this manner there are just as many that don’t or that may be questioning their long held beliefs of bigotness,racism etc. I stay around as an example. So they can see my life, my relationship, my life as a human being is just as valid and worthy as theirs. If we isolate ourselves within our own subculture how can others know us on a personal level? If they don’t know us they will continue to believe we are a different species or worse. We must be the stewards of our own equality. We must become teachers to the uneducated and participants in life with our fellow citizens gay or straight. Not every person’s opinion will be swayed but it will go a long way in our cause for equality.
April 7, 2010 at 6:00 pm
Kat
My heart broke when I heard about the fake prom (I saw it on Rachel Maddow before I read your blog)… My heart broke again tonight learning that you, an empowering voice in my life via blogland, was so outraged that you felt like giving up, even if just for a second. That’s what hate does. It robs us all.
I know that good will come from this. Ridiculous amounts of good have to come from the idiots who made such a trite move in the midst of mass media attention. I am crossing my fingers that Constance gets a scholarship to somewhere amazing, to do something amazing and change people’s lives for years to come. Her life is never going to be the same.
I will gladly be Pollyanna and say that I am looking forward to how this situation is going to change our culture, particularly for teenage queers who need all the advocacy they can get. Imagine all the schools who won’t dare discriminate after the attention Constance brought this spring. Imagine all the little baby dykes she inspired to wear tuxes next year.
I am convinced more good than we will ever know will come from this situation. <3
April 8, 2010 at 9:53 am
jessejames
Thank you very much for your “Pollyanna” perspective, Kat. It is an important and very necessary lens, especially right now. I agree with you totally, by the way, that more good than anything else will come from this situation. Thanks for the great comment.
April 8, 2010 at 11:44 am
e
I’ll second that Pollyanna attitude. I’m angry, sad, demoralized, but yes, there could be a silver lining. Thanks for pointing it out.